Facebook rejects creepy ads that show how much data it collects about you

It’s no secret that Facebook, Instagram and WhatsApp collect a fair bit user data. But how much exactly? A new blog post by the makers of Signal, the open-source secure messaging platform, shows that it’s quite a lot.

“You got this ad because you’re a newlywed Pilates instructor and you’re cartoon crazy,” reads one ad that Signal had planned to run on Instagram. “This ad used your location to see you’re in La Jolla [a San Diego suburb]. You’re into parenting blogs and thinking about LGBTQ adoption.”

“You got this ad because you’re a Goth barista and you’re single,” reads another prospective ad. “This ad used your location to see you’re in Clinton Hill [a Brooklyn neighborhood]. And you’re either vegan or lactose intolerant and you’re really feeling that yoga lately.”

Signal planned to run these ads on Instagram targeting people who fit those specific profiles — and freak them out with how specific each ad was. 

“The ad would simply display some of the information collected about the viewer which the advertising platform uses,” explained Signal’s Jun Harada in the Signal blog post today (May 4). 

Unfortunately, Harada addes, “Facebook was not into that idea,” and Signal’s Facebook ad account was disabled.

Two ads by Signal that were rejected from Instagram.

(Image credit: Signal)

That’s a shame, because as Harada explained in the blog post, “the way most of the internet works today would be considered intolerable if translated into comprehensible real-world analogs, but it endures because it is invisible.”

“Facebook’s own tools have the potential to divulge what is otherwise unseen,” he added. “We wanted to use those same tools to directly highlight how most technology works.”

We ourselves didn’t quite understand what was going on here. Was Facebook collecting information about specific individuals and then delivering that information to advertisers? So we called Harada (on Signal, of course) for more information.

He explained to us that it’s the other way around. Facebook has a tool called the Facebook Ad Manager that you can try using yourself. 

It lets you create ad campaigns targeted to very specific demographic groups and interests, for example women between 25 and 35 who are into country music, mountain biking and liberal politics. Or it can get even more granular, as evidenced by the ads Signal wanted to run.

A screen shot of the Facebook Ad Manager life-event selection tool.

(Image credit: Facebook)

Basically, Harada told us, you can use the Facebook Ad Manager to create your ideal targeted person. Facebook will find real people who come close to matching that ideal person and send those people your ads. 

You can create a target audience based on location, interests, relationship status, hobbies, activities, ethnicity, level of education, number of children, job titles and, at least in the United States, politics.

A screen grab of the part of the Facebook Ad Manager tool that targets audience by political affiliation.

(Image credit: Facebook)

So it’s not quite as creepy as Facebook pulling out all the details about you or me as individuals and sending that to advertisers. The advertisers never see your actual data. But it’s still pretty jarring to read ads that seem crafted specifically for you.

Or, at least, it would have been had Facebook permitted Signal to go ahead with those Instagram ad buys. 

Ironically, Harada noted in the blog post, “being transparent about how ads use people’s data is apparently enough to get banned” from Facebook’s ad platform.

“In Facebook’s world,” he added, “the only acceptable usage is to hide what you’re doing from your audience.”

Leave a Comment